How do I get published in the highest ranked journals? In recent years
academics have become preoccupied with securing and amassing a portfolio of
3* and 4* publications. Some argue this has been to the detriment of quality and
scholarly integrity – part of a logic of governance and managerialism that is
slowly but surely destroying what is most valuable and distinctive in scholarship
and research. Others have argued that a system of quality measurement and
quality ranking makes transparent the ‘rules of the game’ and helps researchers
understand how and why papers get published in the top journals. Rankings
draw a clear line in the sand in ways that prevent a riotous free-for-all in which
everyone can claim to be publishing research of excellence and international
standing.

Manchester Business School will host a debate and seminar amongst the 4 key
protagonists to this debate as it has taken shape in business and management
studies. The four speakers are:

• Hugh Willmott, University of Cardiff
• Mick Rowlinson, Queen Mary University
• Stuart Macdonald, University of Sheffield and
• Huw Morris, University of Salford

In the customary manner of debate, each keynote will lay out and speak
in defence of their position, before their opposite number responds, to which the
protagonist has a brief right of reply. We will then invite questions and answers
amongst audience members. In response to this debate Professor Ian Stronach
will offer reflections on the wider questions and implications for education and
policy to which each of the protagonists will be invited to respond.
This event is free of charge but the number of participants will be strictly
restricted to 35. If you wish to attend please book a place by contacting Damian
O’Doherty (damian.odoherty@mbs.ac.uk). Registration will begin from 9am with
coffee and tea. Lunch and refreshments provided.