Theme 3 Research Projects
(1) Selling Risk: The Making of Life Assurance Markets 1774-1911
Liz McFall
This inquiry adopted two lines of investigation. The first centered upon the promotion of life assurance through devices including the use of agents, sales promotion, publicity and corporate promotion. Archival research revealed an array of devices including advertisements, prospectuses, trade press and handbooks while photographic evidence was collected to record the use of architecture as promotional spectacle. The second line of investigation concentrated on the changing character of insurance as a technique of liberal government through analysis of primary sources including government reports, journal articles, newspaper correspondence and company histories. This revealed a generality of form enabling insurance to ‘fit’ both socialised and privatised actuarial schemes matched by large companies’ ability to adapt to changing governmental priorities.
- McFall, E. R., (2008) Advertising, History of International Encyclopaedia of Communication, Oxford: Blackwell.
- McFall, E. R., (2007) ‘Prudentialism and the ‘Missionaries’ of Life Assurance’, CRESC Working Paper, number 32,
- McFall, E. R., (2007) ‘Which Half?: Accounting for Ideology in Advertising’, in Critical Marketing: Issues & Approaches, Elliot, R. (ed.), Elsevier.
- McFall, E. R., and Dodsworth, F., (forthcoming 2008) ‘Fabricating the Market: The Promotion of Life Assurance in the Long Nineteenth Century’, Journal of Historical Sociology, 21 (3)
- McFall, E. R., (forthcoming 2008) ‘Devices and Desires: how useful is the new economic sociology of market attachment?’, Sociology Compass.
(2) The State of Freedom
Patrick Joyce
This inquiry related to a larger book exploring how the liberal British state historically became embedded in techno-social forms. It considered the techno-social forms of the state in terms of the example of the historical emergence of communications systems, centered on the British Post Office. This has given rise to a CRESC online working paper, entitled Postal communication and the making of the British technostate.
- Bennett, T., Dodsworth, F., Joyce, P. (2007) ‘Introduction: Liberalisms, Government, Culture’, Cultural Studies 21 (4-5), pp 525-48, ISSN 0950-2386 print / 1466-4348 online. This forms the introduction to a special double issue of the journal edited by these authors.
- Bennett, T., Joyce, P., (forthcoming 2009) Material Powers: Essays beyond Cultural Materialism, for publication in Routledge CRESC series, London: Routledge.
- Joyce, P., (in progress) The Soul of Leviathan: Making the British Technostate.
(3) Reinventing Oxbridge and the Public School
Patrick Joyce
This inquiry concerned the successive and successful reinventions of two primary locations of power and influence in British society: the public school and the Oxbridge college. The first period covered is the late 19th century, the second post-1945 Britain. Attention was paid to the curriculum, teaching methods, discipline, and the corporate identity and spatial forms of institutions, the emphasis being placed on the inculcation of the capacity to govern and to ‘lead’. The emphasis is on the materialities of pedagogy throws up new understandings of how power operated in British society, and therefore new possibilities for re-interpreting the course of British history.
- Joyce, P., (in progress) The Soul of Leviathan: Making the British Technostate.
(4) The Built Environment and the Formation of Liberal Elites in England and Germany around 1900
Maiken Umbach
This offered a comparative analysis of the formation of liberal subjectivities in Britain and Germany at the outset of the twentieth century, arguing that the German notion of Bürgerlichkeit not be read as an expression of German middle–class consciousness, but as a political project, which ran parallel with the emergence of liberal governmentality in Britain. This analogy was the result of a significant entanglement of developments in both countries. This complicates a more detailed comparison, as no two cases can be analytically isolated and then compared: for example, the performance and disciplining of the liberal self were primarily associated with the domestic sphere in fin-de-siècle Germany, yet more typically carried out by and through public spaces and practices, such as school classrooms and team sports, in Britain.
- Umbach, M., (2006) ‘Regionalism in Modern European Nation-States’, in Hewitson, M., and Baycroft, T., (eds.), Nationalism in Europe, 1789-1914: Civic and Ethnic Traditions, Oxford University Press.
- Umbach, M., (forthcoming early 2009) German Cities and Bourgeois Modernism, 1890-1924, Oxford University Press.
(5) Reconfiguring 'Global Citizenship' and 'Global Governance': The Role of Boundaries, Frontiers, Territories, Jurisdictions and Distances
Grahame Thompson
This inquiry examined what the two main monotheist religious fundamentalisms – Islam and Christianity - have had to say about the international system, and in particular their attitudes towards, and visions of, ‘globalisation’. It explored the attitudes of these positions towards the idea of ‘territory’ since this is one of those categories that is more widely at stake in the general discussion of globalisation and its consequences, and assessed the impact of these doctrines on the conduct of international relations.
- Thompson, G., (2006) ‘Religious Fundamentalisms, Territories and Globalization’, CRESC Working Paper, number.14.
- Thompson, G., (2006) ‘Trans-territoriality and liberal governance’, CRESC News 3, July 2006, pp 4.
A5.108 Trigg, - Thompson, G., (forthcoming 2008) ‘The interrelationship between Global and Corporate Governance: Towards a democratization of the Business Firm?’, in Handbook on Research on Corporate Citizenship, A. Scherer & G. Palazzo (eds.), Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
(6) The Architecture of Administration: Building the Liberal State, c 1750-1950
Francis Dodsworth
The first stage of the project involved study of the construction of William Kent’s Treasury building under the Walpole administration in the 1730s. This was the first purpose-built government office in London and established the dominance of Palladianism in public building at this time. The intellectual drive behind this project was to push analysis of political culture beyond the textual statements usually studied by historians of politics and political thought into the material domain. Further work is developing in the field of the administrative structures and civic spaces of local government, from the late eighteenth to the late nineteenth century.
- Dodsworth, F. (2005) ‘Virtus on Whitehall: The Politics of Palladianism in William Kent’s Treasury Building, 1733-6’, Journal of Historical Sociology, Vol.18, (4), pp 282-317.
(7) Liberalism and Police: Biopolitics and the Government of Conduct in Britain, c. 1750-1850
Francis Dodsworth
The initial stages of this project saw exploration of the persona idealised for the parish constable before the creation of the new police and the way this ideal was transformed under the impact of the creation of paid policemen. Later work focused on the definition of the concept of the prevention of crime in the late eighteenth century, analysing the way individual vice was defined as a public problem, the solution to which was moral regulation of the environment. Further work explores the idea of police as a broad mechanism of uniform, co-ordinated urban regulation designed to manage this issue.
- Dodsworth, F., (2007) ‘Police and the Prevention of Crime: Commerce, Temptation and the Corruption of the Body Politic, from Fielding to Colquhoun’, British Journal of Criminology, 47 (3) 2007, pp. 439-454. ISSN 0007-0955 print / 1464-3529 online.
- Bennett, T., Dodsworth, F., Joyce, P. (2007) ‘Introduction: Liberalisms, Government, Culture’, Cultural Studies 21 (4-5), pp 525-48, ISSN 0950-2386 print / 1466-4348 online. This forms the introduction to a special double issue of the journal edited by these authors.
- Dodsworth, F., (2007) ‘Masculinity as Governance: Police, Public Service and the Embodiment of Authority, c. 1700-1850’, in M. L. McCormack, ed., Public Men: Masculinity and Politics in Modern Britain, London: Palgrave, pp. 33-53. ISBN 0230-007635.
- Dodsworth, F., (2007) ‘Liberty and Order in Eighteenth-Century England: Civil Liberty, Civil Government and the Common Good’, conference paper available online via the Political Studies Association at: http://www.psa.ac.uk/2007/pps/Dodsworth.pdf
- Dodsworth, F., (2006) ‘Liberty and Order: Civil Government and the Common Good in Eighteenth-Century England’, CRESC Working Papers Series, No. 21.
- Dodsworth F., and Bailey, M.. ed. (under review) Liberal Government: History, Practice, Technology, submitted to Palgrave 11 July 2007.
- Dodsworth, F., (forthcoming) ‘The Idea of Police in Eighteenth-Century England: Discipline, Reformation, Superintendence, c. 1780-1800’, Journal of the History of Ideas.
- Dodsworth, F., (under review) ‘Liberty, law and restraint in English charges to the grand jury, c. 1714-45’, submitted to Historical Research.
- Dodsworth, F,. (under review) ‘Civil Liberty and Government of the Passions in Eighteenth- Century England: Habit and Education in Virtue’, submitted to History of Political Thought.
(8) Cultural Diversity: New Sporting Identities?
Kath Woodward
This study of the operation of diversity policies and practices in football, demonstrated some of the tensions and contradictions of diversity, suggesting the emergence new identifications, along a continuum, from the human rights discourse of activists, the utilitarian positions of football club ‘community’ workers and administrators and the charity situated identities, which are largely indicative of the pastiche of multi-culture. Diversity politics, however can open up possibilities and challenge the negativity of some contemporary critics.
- Woodward, K., (2007) ‘Embodied Identities’ in Wellard I. (ed.) Re-Thinking Gender and Sport, London: Routledge, pp.23-36, ISBN: 978 04115410 922
- Woodward, K., (2007) Real Men? Boxing and Masculinity, in Berkowitz,M. and Ungar, R. (eds) Fighting Back? Jewish and Black Boxers in Britain, London: UCL, the Jewish Museum, pp.95-106, ISBN: 978-0-9555547-0-4.
- Woodward, K. (2005) ‘On and Off the Pitch: Diversity policies and transforming identities?’,
CRESC Working Paper, number 8.
A5.118 *Wright, D., (2007) ‘Watching The Big Read with Pierre Bourdieu: Forms of heteronomy - Woodward, K., (forthcoming Dec 2008), Embodied Sporting Practices: Regulating Bodies: Bodies, London, Palgrave.
- Woodward, K., (forthcoming 2008) ‘Still Rumblin’ in Silk, M.,. (ed.) Physical Cultural Studies Anthology, Pennsylvania, Temple Press.
- Woodward, K., (forthcoming 2008) ‘Boxing Bodies, Boxing Cultures’ in Jackson, R., and Murali Balaji, M., (eds.) Culturing Manhood & Masculinities, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Woodward, K., (forthcoming 2008) ‘Bodies on the Margins’, Leisure Studies, Journal.
- Woodward, K. (forthcoming 2008) ‘Hanging Out and Hanging About: insider and outsider research in the sport of boxing’, Ethnography, Special Edition, No10, 4/5 July 2008.
(9) Technologies of Racial and Cultural Diversity
Peter Wade
In years 1-3, on-going research on the intersection of public knowledge of genetics and biotechnology with ideas of racial-ethnic difference revealed the persistence in popular usage of established discourses of ‘blood’, accompanied by new possibilities for reckoning kinship and genetic/blood connections (through IVF and transnational adoption) that both reinforced and unsettled established ways of thinking about race. No single trend was found. This research has led into an enquiry - currently in progress - on the intersection of race and sexuality as mutually constituting domains in changing modes of governance in Latin America. - A1.19, A1.2.19, A2.77, A2.2.38.
- Harvey, P., Edwards, J., Wade, P., (eds.) (2008) Technologized Images, Technologized Bodies: anthropological approaches to a new politics of vision, Oxford: Berghahn.
- Wade, P., (ed) (2007) Race, ethnicity and nation: perspectives from kinship and genetics, Oxford: Berghahn Books. ISBN 978-1-84545-355-7.
- Wade, P., (2007) ‘Race, ethnicity and nation: perspectives from kinship and genetics’, in Race, ethnicity and nation: perspectives from kinship and genetics. Edited by Peter Wade, Oxford: Berghahn Books: 1-31. ISBN 978-1-84545-355-7.
- Wade, P., (forthcoming 2008) Raza, etnicidad y sexualidades: ciudadanía y multiculturalismo en América Latina, edited by Fernando Urrea, Mara Viveros and Peter Wade. Bogotá: Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Universidad del Valle.
- Wade, P., (forthcoming) ‘Race, identité et parenté’, New Directions in Kinship, edited by Enric Porqueres, Paris: EHESS.
(10) Cosmopolitan Cultures and Urban Governance
Sophie Watson
The focus of this inquiry was a study of the relationship between migrant cultures and established churches in the local area of Marrickville Sydney. An ethnographic study was carried out of 6 religious sites. Priests and pastors were interviewed from the different religious traditions to investigate their role in forging links with local communities, in building networks, and in providing a site where cultural traditions from a place of origin could be adapted and enacted in the absence of local public facilities. Participant observation was also carried out. The study found a variable level of shifts in dominant practices and of interaction with migrant groups. The study concluded that churches had the potential to operate as an important site of community, belonging, and the performance of significant cultural practices for migrants in the locality.
- Watson, S., Dodsworth, F., (submitted) ‘Into Unorthodox London: The Religious Ethnography of Charles Maurice Davies’, Journal of Victorian Culture.
- Watson, S., (in progress) ‘Brief Encounters of an unpredictable kind: Everyday Multiculturalism in three London street markets’, for A. Wise (ed) Everyday Multiculturalism, London: Palgrave.
- Watson, S., (submitted) ‘Performing Religion: Migrants, the church and belonging in Marrickville, Sydney’, Journal of Sociology.
- Watson, S., (in progress) ‘Public Potentialities’ requested for Urban Design.
(11) Legal Knowledges, Citizenship and Cultural Change in the People' Republic of China
Susanne Brandtstädter
This inquiry focused on 'law activists' in China, who use legal mechanisms to 'get their right' in cases of government abuse. What emerged was that activists reinterprete legal processes as political processes and form new forms of social relations around 'law'. The relevance of law for these activists lies as much in emphasising and demonstrating problems of government. Law is used to 'rebalance' relations between local communities and the government, with attaining justice and the improvement of rural livelihood being part of this process, rather than simply the result of court decisions.
- Brandtstädter, S., (2006) with Schubert, G., ‘Democratic Thought and Practice in Rural China’, in Faundez, Julio, (ed.), On the State of Democracy, London: Routledge. (Reprint of Journal Issue).
- Brandtstädter, S., (2006) ‘Muddled Modernities in Peasant China’, CRESC Working Paper, number 18.
(12) Making Culture, Changing Society
Tony Bennett
By drawing on assemblage theory this inquiry has developed a distinctive theoretical approach to the historical development of a ‘culture complex’ comprising a network of institutions in cultural resources are assembled in ways that format the social in ways that conducive to particular ways if intervening in and managing and directing. The argument has been developed empirically in relation to the role of anthropological collection in colonial administration during the early development of the fieldwork phase in anthropology.
- Bennett, T., (2008) 'Sociology and culture' in T. Bennett and J. Frow (eds.) Handbook of Cultural Analysis, London: Sage.
- Bennett, T., (2008) ‘Anthropological assemblages: producing culture as a surface of government’, CRESC Working Paper, number 52.
- Bennett, T., Dodsworth, F., Joyce, P., (eds.) (2007) ‘Liberalism, government, culture’, a special double issue of Cultural Studies, volume 21, numbers 4-5, July/September 2007.
- Bennett, T., Dodsworth, F., Joyce, P. (2007) ‘Introduction: Liberalisms, Government, Culture’, Cultural Studies, 21 (4-5), pp 525-48, ISSN 0950-2386 print / 1466-4348 online. This forms the introduction to a special double issue of the journal edited by these authors.
- Bennett, T., (2007) 'Making culture, changing society: the perspective of culture studies', Cultural Studies, vol 21, nos 4-5, pp 610-629.
- Bennett, T., (2007) 'The work of culture', Journal of Cultural Sociology, vol 1, no. 1, pp 31-48.
- Bennett T., (2006) ‘Exhibition, difference and the logic of culture’, in I. Karp and C. Kratz (eds.), Museum Frictions: Public Cultures/Global Transformations, Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
- Bennett, T., (2005) ‘Civic laboratories: museums, cultural objecthood, and the governance of the social’, Cultural Studies, 19 (5), pp 521-547.
- Bennett, T. (2005) ‘Civic laboratories: museums, cultural objecthood, and the governance of the social’, CRESC Working Paper, number 2.
- Bennett, T., (forthcoming 2008) 'The art museum as civic machinery' in Jaschke, B., Martinz- Turek, C. and Sternfeld, N. (eds.) Sammlungen Austellen, Vienna: Verlag Turia + Kant (in press).
- Bennett, T., Joyce, P., (forthcoming 2009) Material Powers: Essays beyond Cultural Materialism, for publication in Routledge CRESC series, London: Routledge.
- Bennett (forthcoming 2009) 'Making and mobilising worlds: Museums, expeditions, and the management of culture' in Bennett and Joyce (eds.) Material Powers: Essays Beyond the Cultural Materialism, London: Routledge.
- Bennett, T., and Healy, C., (eds.) (forthcoming 2009) ‘Assembling Culture’, special double issue of the Journal of Cultural Economy.
- Bennett (forthcoming 2009) 'Reassembling the other: museums and colonial and regional governance in mid-twentieth century France', Journal of Cultural Economy.
- Bennett (forthcoming 2009) 'Aesthetics and the social' [working title], Parallax: Journal of Cultural Studies.
(13) Ordering Differences: Museum Practices and Cultural Diversity
Tony Bennett
This inquiry has focused on identifying different visual grammars of difference in contemporary museum practice and their relevance to contemporary debates concerning the relations between museums and cultural diversity. The cases examined include new exhibitions at the British Museum and the Bunjilaka Gallery in the Museum of Melbourne. A theoretical and historical aspect of the inquiry has examined the operation of different forms of ‘civic seeing’ associated with the historical development of the modern museum.
- Bennett T., (2006) ‘Civic seeing: museums and the organisation of vision’, in MacDonald, S., (eds.), Companion to Museum Studies, Oxford: Blackwell.
- Bennett T., (2006) ‘Culture and differences: the challenges of multiculturalism’ in Boda, S., and Cifarelli, M.R., (eds.), When Culture Makes the Difference: Heritage, Arts and Media in Multicultural Society, Rome: Meltemi Editore, pp. 21–37. Also in French and Spanish translation in Negrier, E. (ed) La fin des cultures nationales?
- Bennett, T., (2005) ‘Civic laboratories: museums, cultural objecthood, and the governance of the social’, Cultural Studies, 19 (5), pp 521-547.
(14) Shaping Citizens? An Investigation into Visitor Learning in Manchester Museums
Helen Rees Leahy
The project addressed two main questions: 1) what kinds of knowledges (including embodied skills and competences) are instrumentalised via the collecting, display and interpretative practices of art exhibitions and museums, and; 2) how do these ‘official’ knowledges relate to, and/or take account of, the ‘unofficial’ knowledges of museum visitors? The 1857 Manchester Art Treasures Exhibition was developed as a case study, based on archival research in Manchester and London, so as to elucidate the production of an urban public for art, based on analysis of the socio-cultural encounters of diverse visitors. In turn, research findings on the 19th century inculcation of techniques of exhibition visiting were used to inform the centrality of bodily relations to the museum’s potential as an agent and site of social change.
- Rees Leahy, H., (forthcoming 2008) ‘‘Fix'd statue on the pedestal of Scorn’: The politics and poetics of displaying the Parthenon Marbles in Athens and London in 2004’, in Dowson, T., (ed) Art and Archaeology, Aldershot: Ashgate.
- Rees Leahy, H., (forthcoming) ‘`Walking for Pleasure`? Bodies of Display at the 1857 Manchester Art-Treasures Exhibition’, Art History Special Issue Display and Spectacle.
Publications contributed to this theme by Visiting Fellows:
- Ruppert, E. S. (2007) ‘Producing Population’, CRESC Working Paper, number 37.
- Rindzeviciute, E., (2005) ‘The Rise of Cybernetics? Government and Change in Lithuanian Cultural Policy’, CRESC Working Paper, number 10.
- Saunders, D., (2006) ‘What does liberalism inherit from early modern religious settlements’, CRESC Working Paper, number 16.
- Southerton, D., Cheng, S-L., Olsen, W., and Warde, A., (2007) ‘Trajectories of time spent reading as a primary activity: a comparison of the Netherlands, Norway, France, UK and USA since the 1970s’, CRESC Working Paper, number 39.
